Separating Fact from Fiction: Common Antidepressant Myths
Reading Time: 5 minutes
_____
Summary:
-
Common antidepressant myths—like addiction and personality change—are false
-
Antidepressants reduce symptoms without altering identity or causing cravings
-
They take 4-6 weeks to work and support long-term health recovery
-
These medications help brain function beyond boosting serotonin levels
-
Taking antidepressants is a medically sound step, not a sign of weakness
_____
Antidepressants are among the most commonly prescribed medications for mental health conditions, offering vital support to millions globally. Despite their widespread use, many misconceptions persist, leading to fears and hesitations that may prevent individuals from seeking necessary treatment.
In this article, we debunk the prevalent myths surrounding antidepressants, explore how they work based on scientific evidence, and emphasize the importance of making informed decisions for mental health care.
Myth no. 1: “Antidepressants are addictive.”
Concerns about addiction often hinder people from considering antidepressants. However, this confusion arises from mixing up the ideas of “dependence” and “addiction.”
Unlike substances that are addictive, antidepressants do not lead to cravings or compulsive behaviors. Patients do not experience a “high”, nor do they increase their doses to sustain an effect.
While some may encounter withdrawal symptoms, known as “discontinuation syndrome,” if they suddenly stop taking certain antidepressants, healthcare providers advise gradual tapering under supervision. Nonetheless, this process differs significantly from breaking a true addiction.
Myth no. 2: "Antidepressants will alter your personality."
Many worry that antidepressants might change their identity or dull their feelings. However, the main goal of treatment is to reduce depression symptoms, like persistent sadness, tiredness, and hopelessness, without altering who you are. When these symptoms improve, many people report feeling more like themselves.
A potential side effect is "emotional blunting,” where emotions feel less intense. If this happens, consult your doctor to adjust your medication and find a treatment that suits you.
Myth no. 3: “Antidepressants provide a quick solution."
Many believe antidepressants offer quick relief, but they typically take 4-6 weeks to work effectively. They are not quick fixes or immediate mood stabilizers. Instead, they are an element of a broader, long-term treatment plan.
Recovery from depression generally requires multiple approaches, such as therapy, lifestyle changes, and social support. Although antidepressants are not a perfect solution, when combined with other strategies, they can greatly improve quality of life.
Myth no. 4: "Antidepressants simply increase serotonin levels."
A common and oversimplified view is that antidepressants work by simply increasing serotonin in the brain. While many, especially selective serotonin reuptake inhibitors (SSRIs), do impact serotonin, this explanation is incomplete.
Research indicates that antidepressants also affect various neurotransmitter systems and can enhance neuroplasticity—the brain’s ability to adapt—and neurogenesis, which is the growth of new neurons. This suggests that antidepressants create a brain environment that supports recovery from depression, rather than merely fixing a single chemical imbalance.
Withdrawal Is Real — Here’s What Helps
Antidepressant discontinuation symptoms can be mild for many but moderate to severe and longer-lasting for some. The best prevention is a personalized, gradual taper (sometimes over months) with a plan to distinguish withdrawal from depression relapse. If symptoms are significant, clinicians may pause the taper or adjust the schedule.
Myth no. 5: “Taking antidepressants means you’re weak or can’t cope.”
Cultural stigma and misconceptions about mental illness create a false contrast between “strong” people who tough it out and “weak” ones who need medication. This belief often arises in societies that glorify resilience and self-reliance.
But depression isn’t a lack of willpower—it’s a medical condition involving biological, psychological, and environmental factors. Medication doesn’t erase emotional resilience; it restores the neurochemical balance that enables resilience. In fact, taking antidepressants often reflects self-awareness and courage—the willingness to seek help and take active steps toward healing.
Myth no. 6: “Everyone has the same side effects."
Different people will experience different side effects from antidepressant use. Many factors—such as your genetics, age, metabolic rate, and other medications you might be taking—affect how you respond to these drugs. Some people may experience issues like nausea, weight fluctuations, or sleep problems, while others might not notice any side effects at all.
If one medication doesn’t suit you or causes unwanted effects, there are numerous alternatives available. Additionally, most side effects can be managed effectively with guidance from a healthcare professional.
Starting, Switching, or Stopping: Why Monitoring Matters
Antidepressants can help many people, but the first weeks after starting, changing the dose, or stopping are when extra check-ins are important. In children, teens, and some young adults, there’s a known increase in suicidal thoughts/behaviors when starting treatment; families should watch closely and contact the prescriber if concerns arise. Never stop abruptly—taper with your clinician and report withdrawal symptoms (e.g., dizziness, “brain zaps,” anxiety, insomnia).
Do Antidepressants ‘Cause’ Suicide?
The link between antidepressants and suicide is complex, not black-and-white. In adults, these medicines generally reduce depressive symptoms and can lower overall suicide risk as depression improves. In children, teens, and some young adults, however, studies show a temporary increase in suicidal thoughts or behaviors when starting treatment, which is why the FDA includes a boxed warning. Sudden dose changes or stopping can also heighten emotional distress, so it’s vital to taper under medical supervision and stay in close contact with your care team during those adjustment periods.
The bottom line
Antidepressants are frequently misunderstood; however, they are important for managing depression. By addressing common misconceptions and providing evidence-based information, we can help decrease stigma and encourage people to consider effective treatment options.
It’s also important to recognize that depression is more than just feeling sad; it’s a serious health condition comparable to illnesses like diabetes or cancer. Just as any other organ can malfunction, the brain can also experience dysfunction, which may require medical treatment.
Additionally, feeling sad does not automatically mean someone has depression, and having depression does not guarantee identical responses to all treatments. Personalized care, based on accurate information and healthcare professionals, is vital for successful management.
Related reading:
How to Find Motivation When You’re Depressed
How to Support Someone With Depression: Words That Help and Hurt
